Community: SDNN vs NCTimes

A novel news service for San Diego launched a site into beta testing this week. Like the North County Times, the SDNN has opted to use blogging as a forum for communicating with the community. Unlike the NC Times, SDNN appears to have based their community forums on open tools allowing community members to participate using their established online persona instead of having to create new accounts inside a walled garden.

While the North County Times should enjoy a comfortable advantage as an incumbent, their inability to adapt to the realities of social media may cripple their ability to form a successful online community.

This post will serve as a test of how SDNN is configured to accept either trackbacks or pingbacks as comments.

[Update Mar 25, 2009]

The pingback appeared internally in their comment system and the count of comments reflects the pinpingback, yet the actual pingback did not appear on the site. I did not receive a reply to my tweet as to whether this was intended behavior.

[Update to the Update]

The pingback does appear on the SDNN blog site as a comment, it still does not appear as a comment on the news site.

Tags: , ,

  • You were able to comment using existing online persona? I had to create a new Wordpress login? I feel like I can't win for trying on the site. Could be something with my Firefox browser or I don't know what...
  • admin
    Since my blog is based on Wordpress, the same software being used by SDNN, posts on my blog that link to SDNN stories are automatically submitted as comments at SDNN. However at this point these comments are only displayed on posts in the A Conversation with San Diego section and not in the stories section. You will see a discrepancy in the number of comments actually displayed and the number of comments indicated at the top of the story. This is actually being accentuated by posts on A Conversation with San Diego that link back to stories (see the 8 Greats). Because of the decision to use two separate blogs the Conversation posts are link to the stories posts as comments.
blog comments powered by Disqus